Thinking-Drinking
  • Blog
  • Erin
  • Index
  • Articles
  • News
  • Podcast
  • Contact

Lava & Light: Alice Bonaccorsi 'ValCerasa' 2009 Etna Bianco (Sicily)

10/14/2013

0 Comments

 
Picture
Last week I was in the middle of an insane day, a day too busy for tasting appointments. But I had some on the calendar and it was too late to cancel. I had a clear two hours of work to do in the next half hour to get ready for the start of restaurant service, and I went into this particular tasting with my eye on speed, my brain racing with an intense priority list, and my heart pounding with stress. I was going to speed taste through the wines and then get back to business. 

When I'm focused for work, nothing can grab my attention away from reprinting wine lists, ordering, and updating the wine list. 

Nothing but a miraculous wine, that is. Sometimes, these unexpected sips can give you just the perspective you need in a hurried day. One sip of this, and it was as if the world stopped and everything that was truly important came into clear focus. 

This taste of Etna carricante certainly gave my night a whole new sense of meaning and wonder. I love having a job where aesthetic magic can surprise you on an almost nightly basis. 




Winemaker Alice Bonaccorsi has a vineyard that one might find in a fairytale. Here, the vines rise above swirling volcano smoke that billows from Etna, the sleeping giant that smolders in the backdrop; and ancient volcano cones from thousands of years ago jut their hard lava cones up from the vineyard like stalagtites in a cave. It's a fantastical setting, and the wine is as magical as from where it comes. 
Picture

Picture
Alice Bonaccorsi 'ValCerasa' 2009 Etna Bianco (Sicily)

Soft, brushed gold in color. Interesting and complex aromas of lees, earth, pear, melon, flowers, grapefruit zest. Rich and dense palate with high acid, but extremely balanced. A weighty texture in the midpalate and and uplifting tartness on the finish. The skin contact is evident, and welcome! Love this.... 

0 Comments

Dirty and Rowdy wine at Rouge Tomate

12/6/2012

1 Comment

 
Picture
Chef Jeremy Bearman and Wine Director Pascaline Lepeltier of Rouge Tomate in Manhattan, New York need little introduction. Chef Bearman has long been a proponent of sustainable and local foods, and Pascaline is a global champion of organic wines.  A few weeks ago they collaborated to put on an amazing wine dinner focused on special wines from the West Coast (West Coast Winemakers' Dinner: A Tribute to Natural Wines).  The wines curated were a telling cross section of a movement gaining momentum in California and Oregon. 
Picture







The line-up included: 

Dirty & Rowdy semillon, 2011
Dirty & Rowdy mourvedre, 2010, 2011
Coturri chardonnay, Grebenikoff 2010
Coturri zinfandel, Estate 2007
Coturri red blend, "Sandocino" NV
Montebruno pinot noir, 2007, 2008, 2009
Hardesty merlot/cab sauv, "Trinity" 2009


Picture
Dirty & Rowdy
Of all the wines we tasted that night, I'm going to focus on just one producer-- Dirty & Rowdy-- because, well, I was sitting next to Hardy Wallace, aka Dirty (one of the winemakers) and we talked mostly about his wines. 

I always wonder what it must feel like for hard-working winemakers who see all the grit--  the dusty, bloomy grapes, the bugs and pests, the mess of the crush, all the gross after-stuff of fermentation, the clean up, the unrelenting, backbreaking, sleeplessness of harvest time-- and then see their finished wine in a leisurely setting like a private dining room in a fancy NYC restaurant, packaged in bottles, served by people in suits, and sipped by well-heeled diners. It must be a trip. Wine is a delicate agricultural product that, at times, can seem so far separated from its farm-based source. The wines served with this dinner are all wines that attempt to bridge the separation that can occur after grapes are transformed into bottles wine, and all are made by small-volume winemakers specifically focused on organic farming and natural winemaking. 

At dinner I sat next to one such winemaker, who goes by his nickname "Dirty," (yes, he is the "Dirty" in Dirty & Rowdy). First, a little bit about Dirty & Rowdy. Two guys: one wine blogger (Dirty South Wine), one former food blogger from Atlanta. They frequently collaborated on their websites, and one day decided to make wine. After quitting their jobs they up and moved to California, then set up shop making wines. I love that this can happen for some people in life. 

Picture

The label has a pretty cool story. 

Dirty and Rowdy have spent hours upon hours up in the Santa Barbera hills at the mourvedre vineyard with old school weed-whackers and clippers. During the weed-whacking, Dirty puts on headphones, but the whacker still creates a constant drone in the background, an almost lulling sound that can make you forget about the two dangers he is always on the lookout for: poisonous snakes and mountain lions. 

When it came time for a label design, they had the idea to be battling snakes and mountain lions with weed-whackers and clippers. Their artist friend took some liberties and made the snake an anaconda, and the mountain lion a formidable tiger. 



After a few glasses and the normal pleasantries, Dirty said something about terroir that made my thoughts wander to drumming (the other big part of my life). We were talking about mourvedre and his choice to make it. I asked "Why mourvedre in Santa Barbera?" He mentioned that the decision was really driven by what desirable parcels were available at that time and which of those fell in their price range. Practical desire. Or maybe more precisely: Desire limited by the confines of practicalness. Winemaking isn't always a result of when-creative-planning-meets-endless-resources; sometimes it is simply taking advantage of what resources are available to you at a particular time. As a new wine label, Dirty & Rowdy has started off like most new labels do: making wine from contracted grapes, with a solid plan to buy their own vineyards in the near future. The mourvedre is a beautiful and unforeseen result of the collision of need and desire. 

Rhythm, Wine, & Expression
As a semi-artistic expression created out of available resources, the genesis of their mourvedre has parallels in other disciplines. As a drummer, I couldn't help but think of the early beginnings of the drum set. The short version is this: marching bands in New Orleans were called upon to play dance music in dance halls. It didn't make economic sense to split up the band money between a cymbal player, a bass drum player, a snare player, etc., so somewhere along the way, one guy got the idea to stick them all together & play them all himself. It caught on fast, and the individual band members all got a bigger cut because of it. The drum set was created happenstance out of available resources and financial restrictions. Each drummer assembled their drum set a bit differently (as they still do today). The idea of a "drum set" is a universal one, yet the enactment of any single particular drum set is one that is personal and distinct and can result in a highly unique configuration based on available resources. In this way, the drum set is much different from most other instruments that are standardized in form (such as the trombone, the violin, the saxophone, and the modern day piano). 

In one of my favorite books that touches on the subject, Percussion: Drumming, Beating, Striking (John Mowitt: 2002), Mowitt makes a statement that has stuck in my brain for years: 

I will approach the trap set as something like an apparatus-- that is, as a configuration of limits and possibilities that are shot through with use, with, in effect, an ensemble of prior engagements, whose significance is distinctly, though perhaps distantly, available to all those touched by the trap set. 
(Mowitt 2002:68)

You could take out the word "trap set" in his statement and replace it with "wine" or "terroir" and get a pretty profound notion of how we use land to create a wide array of wines. 

Though wine and drumming seem like two disjointed subjects, after a glass of wine I had the courage to mention this thought to Dirty. "Ok," I said, "this may sound kind of off-subject, but I play the drums and how your mourvedre came to be kind of reminds me of how drum sets came to be." If he looked disinterested I had a plan to change the subject, fast. 

Dirty paused, looked at me for a minute, and blinked through his glasses. "You play the drums? I play the drums too, I don't think that sounds weird at all." Both our eyebrows raised and something clicked-- like two random guys suddenly realizing that they both were in the same fraternity but from different colleges. 

Picture
It turns out that Dirty is an accomplished tabla drummer who has studied Indian classical music pretty extensively. Is it possible to separate the id of the winemaker/grower from the final product? I don't believe so; and so, I think a brief look at the ideology that informs Indian classical music can serve as a useful prism through which to view the wines of Dirty & Rowdy. 

Indian Classical Music and The Raga
Indian Classical Music traces its deep origins to the Sanskrit Vedas, where the concept of the raga is an integral notion of music. Slightly similar to the concept of a scale (but not quite), the raga is a series of notes used to construct a melody. The raga is integrally linked to mood, time, and place. There are ragas for early morning, ragas for dusk, ragas for the heat of summer, ragas for winter... the idea is that music is linked to the mood of the time and place. How illuminating it is that the etymology of the word raga is hue, and like a hue, a raga is useful in coloring the sonic landscape of time, place, and circumstance. 

A raga has defining parameters, but once inside a raga, a musician has room to stretch and play with improvisation, embellishment, and time. The execution of these sometimes subtle freedoms distinguish good musicians from great ones, and they also allow the musician to tailor the particular performance to what is happening in the moment. 

Is there anything else besides a raga (or music in general) that has the ability to-- each time it is endeavored-- capture and portray a unique collision of time, place, and circumstance? Is there some other human endeavor that also seeks to highlight the beauty and struggle of the passage of time, and then transmit this aesthetic to others in a form consumable by the senses? I'd venture to say that winemaking does just this.  Dirty alluded to this when he once posted on his own wine blog: 

Soil is the music

Grapes are the instrument(s)

Sun is the conductor

(The winemaker selects the speakers and adjusts the volume)



How lucky for us that two wine-obsessed drummers were randomly sat next to each other for this dinner. 
 
The Dinner
And we had dinner.... 
Picture
                
                                                                                                                 

      
                                  Cauliflower Custard                                                                             Dirty & Rowdy Semillon 2011

This was a great pairing. The semillon is grown in Yountville (Napa, CA) and fermented in two different ways. Half of it is skin fermented (orange) and the other half is done in a concrete egg. The two batches are then blended. The skin fermentation adds density, weight, tannin, and texture. The concrete egg portion is interesting-- the shape of the egg forces the CO2 back down into the bottom of the egg, so the contents are always in motion and no cap management is necessary. The finished wine is unfiltered, so it's a bit cloudy-- but nothing to be afraid of! The savory aromas and the richness of texture went so well with the custard and cauliflower. 

Picture
                      Sardines a la Plancha                                         herbed olive oil                                          Sunchoke Farrotto

Picture

This was possibly one of the best pairings of the night. This duck preparation is one of Chef Bearman's classic dishes, and it went beautifully with the Dirty & Rowdy mourvedre. 

Long Island Duck, Moroccan Spices, Fregola Sarda, Baby Turnip, Medjool Date, Beldi Olive, Marcona Almond


Dirty & Rowdy mourvedre 2010 & 2011



And, if you missed it earlier, Dirty & Rowdy and their wives have risked stepping on angry snakes and getting jumped by mountain lions to bring us this high elevation mourvedre from Santa Barbera. Thanks guys! 

Bibliography
Mowitt, John. (2002) Percussion: Drumming, Beating, Striking. Duke University Press: Duhram and London. 
1 Comment

Class on Orange Wine

5/29/2012

0 Comments

 
Picture
Last week I taught a class on orange wine, and some really great  interesting discussions ensued.  

My focus in this class was to present orange wines as products of extended skin contact. There are wines that are orange in color for other reasons, such as the Tondonia Rose-- this is a rose wine that has aged to an orange color-- but these wines to me are not orange; they are oxodized or aged roses. When a red wine turns garnet with age we don't change its category from "red wine" to "garnet wine" because the wine is still the same thing-- the garnet is simply an aged version of the red. The same things applies to white wines: when a white wine ages and becomes golden in hue, we don't change its category from "white wine" to "gold wine;" again, because one is simply an aged version of the other. I think the same should apply to roses. When a rose ages and turns orange in color, it is still a rose-- the orange hued rose is simply an aged version of the rose. 

So, despite the fact that many other somms will categorize oxodized roses as orange, I don't; and for the purpose of this class I presented orange wines as white wines with extended skin contact. The extended skin contact-- to me-- is crucial in the definition of orange wine and the possibilities for flavor profiles within orange wines. 

By categorizing orange wines in this way (i.e. leaving out the aged roses and focusing only on extended skin contact), four distinct wine categories emerge:

White - wine made from white grapes that have had little skin contact
Orange- wine made from white grapes with extended skin contact
Rose- wine made from red grapes that have had little skin contact 
Red- wine made from red grapes that have had extended skin contact

Of course there are tons of exceptions (white wine made from red grapes, white-red blends of roses, viognier in cote rotie, etc.) but as an overarching concept of how orange wine fits into the grander scheme of things, I think the above simplified chart makes the common production methods easily digestible. 

By presenting wine production methods and colors in this way, what emerged in the classroom was a pretty big question: If orange wines are an entire category of wine with just as much production potential as rose, red or white wine, why aren't there more of them? Why are so few being produced?  This is a question I ask myself every day, and I'm pretty baffled by the fact that practically nobody is making these amazing wines. This is an entire untapped category of wine production.  Seriously- imagine a world without rose?  Imagine if people never experimented with little skin-contact in red wines and never created rose?  Imagine the gaping hole that would be left in your lifelong sensory wine experience without rose.  The lack of orange wines on the market is an equally tragic gaping hole in our wine drinking experience.  We are really losing out here. 

Other big questions on the table were: 
With such a global demand for high quality rich and powerful red wines, wouldn't this palate also be more inclined to like a tannin-driven, rich orange wine as opposed to white wine?  Is terroir transmitted or partially transmitted through skin contact, and if so, why have more white wine producers not experimented with extended skin contact as a way to enhance the emergence of terroir in their wines?  With the new idea that what we perceive as minerality in wine is actually sulfides and not, in fact, trace minerals from the soil as we had all assumed/hoped, then wouldn't extended skin contact in white wines be a way to actually get real trace elements from the soil into the wine? 


In the tasting portion of the class we went through: 

Shinn Estate "Skin Fermented Chardonnay" 2009 (North Fork of Long Island, NY)
I chose this wine to taste first-- I wanted to lead the drinkers into orange wine with that familiar chardonnay taste, but presented in a slightly orange way. Baby steps! 

Tissot "Amphore" 2009 (Jura, France)
I chose this wine to taste second- it's completely different from the Shinn and immediately showcased the diversity possible with orange wines. 

Paolo Bea "Chiara" 2009 (Umbria, Italy)
I chose this wine to show third- the color is extremely orange and it's such a classic wine with a great taste. 

Coenobium "Rusticum" 2009 (Lazio, Italy)
I chose this wine to show the diaspora of orange wines within Italy, and to show how Paolo Bea's influence spread to Lazio. 


It ended on a very positive note- lots of people who had never tried it before were really interested in finding out where they could get more.

0 Comments

ORANGE WINES

3/7/2012

5 Comments

 
"Orange wine" refers to white grapes vinified with extended skin contact. Leaving the wine in contact with the skin extracts more tannins, phenolics and color; sometimes a slight oxidativeness accompanies this as well. These processes induce chemical changes that make the wine appear "orange."  Sometimes the color is distinctly orange, at other times it is more coppery and at times there is even a brownish tinge.  Once in a while, an orange wine will look pretty normal (lemon-yellowish) but will still have had extended skin contact.
 
Though they seem new, interesting, and wild, orange wines come from thousands of years of winemaking tradition, most likely first being made in Georgia close to where Vitis vinifera grape vines originated. Practically speaking, it's likely possible that several thousands of years ago most white wines were "orange."  Yeasts that jumpstart fermentation are found naturally on skins, and pre-modern winemakers may have had to leave the skins in longer to take advantage of these native yeast populations to get their white wine fermentations going. Now that the industry better understands yeast and temperature, the winemaker has more control than ever before and does not have to make orange wines. Winemakers have the option to inoculate their must with special yeasts and do not need to rely on naturally occurring yeast populations on the skins.  In fact, most winemaking courses will not even address extended white grape skin contact. A huge emphasis during the last century on sterile, bright, technically-perfect white wine flooded the market with such wines leaving very little room for these interesting and sometimes rustic gems.  They are making a slight comeback-- in part because a younger wine-drinking public is more willing to take risks and try these (sadly) unfamiliar wines.

Another thing that most orange wines have in common is that they are all made by small, artisinal producers. Perhaps this is just because the style of vinification is not mainstream and as such a large company would not  want to invest in such an esoteric product. This may change in the future, but I have yet to come across an orange wine made by a large producer. 

See below for a few classic/standard orange wines that you can hopefully find in your local market. There are plenty of options, but the winemakers below are sort of spear-heading the orange wine phenomenon and influencing other producers in their areas:

Picture
Coebobium (Lazio, Italy) 2009
trebbiano (45%) + malvasia (35%) + verdicchio (20%)
long skin contact + lees aging. 
made by Cistercian nuns and Giampiero Bea (Paolo Bea's son)


This wine has some extended skin contact, but not enough to elicit that dark orange color. Still, you can taste the heaviness in the wine, and the more intense skin tannins. 


Picture
Coebobium "Rusticum" (Lazio, Italy) 2009
trebbiano (45%) + malvasia (35%) + verdicchio (20%)
even longer skin contact than the preivous. 
made by Cistercian nuns and Giampiero Bea

By comparing the color of this first photo and the second photo it's easy to see that extended skin contact really does impart an orange color to the wine. These photos demonstrate that the longer the skins are in contact with the wine, the darker the color will become. 

Picture
Paolo Bea "Chiara" (Umbria, Italy) 2009
grechetto (20%) + malvasia (20%) + garganega (20%) + 2 other types 
15 days of skin contact
made by Paolo Bea (Giampiero's father)

This one is super complex: fresh cut apricots, persimmon, citrus, spice, flowers, nectar, oregano. 

Definitely decant this one-- the photo shows the sediment all mixed up in the wine (we opened this bottle after traveling with it)


Picture
Paolo Bea "Arboreus" (Umbria, Italy) 2006
trebbiano spoletino

A beautiful specimen. This here is one of the benchmarks of orange wine. It's expensive, but worth the experience if you can find a bottle of this. Made from high-trained vines that echo a vine growing in a tree (hence the name arboreus). 

21 days of skin contact
232 days on the lees


Picture
Tissot savagnin "Amphore" (Arbois, France) 2010


skin maceration for 3 months

This one is pretty amazing- ripe pear and fresh cut valencia orange aromas, rich in tannins. truly unique and very special. 


A few other iconic producers to look into are Movia (Lunar), Camillo Donati, Gravner, Pheasant's Tears, and The Prince in His Caves. 

Personally, I find orange wines to be interesting, refreshing, tart, unique and great food wines-- their heavier weight allows them to be paired with wines that would normally require something like a pinot noir. I also think they go great with-- and I hope it isn't just placebic-- oranges. Imagine one of these wines with cod or aparagus in a tart lemon sauce with orange zest on top-- or even a fresh cut orange. They also require some mental attention-- they are not like quaffing whites that you can just drink on a hot day at the beach and practically forget that you are drinking wine. These wines tend to be brooding and sentimental. You'll want to sit down and really think about what you are drinking. Good wines to drink if you are, say, working on your PhD dissertation and need some philosophical stimulation or sitting on the porch trying to make a major life decision. Also big enough for unique food pairings. Great with cheese. 

At the moment orange wines are a minority of production and critics will often frame them as a sommelier's geek-wine recommended for their obscurity. One magazine, for instance, jovially frames them as "a current favorite of hipster sommeliers." Another article mentions that orange wines are a "category gaining favor among some younger, edgier sommeliers."  Though I've sensed that this is the current climate I do believe that there could be a larger space for these wines in the world. They are beautiful in their own way. They are also hearty and pretty resistant to oxidation (which means they are great glass pours because an open bottle will not spoil as fast). It's funny how these wines are framed by the media as hipster & edgy, while the winemakers are usually older and mature with a penchant for philosophy. The impetus for producing an orange wine is usually a pastoral desire to create something natural and expressive, an honest and hardworking wine that conveys an almost spiritual message. It's too bad (or maybe good, for marketing?) that they've gained a rep as odd-ball food-fashion accessories, and that this branding may hold them back from gaining any real ground or a serious following. But then again maybe the small market is actually a good thing since the production is relatively small as it is. In any case, I'm a serious follower, and I know a few others, so all is not lost-- even if we are just an army of a dozen!

Now that my allegiances to orange wine are clear, there is still a sticky philosophical quandry to be tackled about them. Some terroirists believe that terroir comes from the soil and the ground, that this voice is transmitted through juice, and they might argue that extended maceration reduces the expression of terroir because the anthocyanins/phenolics/etc extracted from the skin mask the soil flavors in the juice. They see extended maceration as an unnecessary cellar intervention that overpowers the voice of the soil.

But there is another way to frame it. The skins of the grape may well be as much transmitters of what the soil is saying equally as much as the juice inside the grape; after all they both come from molecules that are sucked up from the soil by the vine. In red wines it is rarely argued that skin contact interferes with terroir, why should this not be the case with white wines as well? Perhaps extended skin contact for white wines is merely a different expression (to which we are unaccustomed?) of terroir-- perhaps the definition of terroir could be broadened to include phenolic and anthocyanin shades in white wines as strong but place-specific conduits for what the earth is saying. 

Debates/stances/discussions on terroir run deep and cannot possibly be fully explored in the above two paragraphs; but it is a beginning, a conversation starter if you will, and an important issue to be aware of when talking about orange wines-- especially to wine professionals who are likely to have a passionate opinion for or against. 

Regardless of your nuanced stances on terroir or "hipster" wines, I believe this breed of wines is too interesting and unique (and delicious!) not to try. 


orange wine   orange wine   orange wine   orange wine   orange wine   orange wine   orange wine   orange wine   orange wine

5 Comments

An Esoteric Tasting

2/29/2012

0 Comments

 
I got together with my girls yesterday (a group of girlfriends in the wine industry). We meet about once a month and blind taste for fun and exercise. Yesterday's theme: "esoteric." Essentially, we all had to bring an odd-ball wine. Here are some of the fun ones that came to the party: 

Picture
Bermejo Malvasia Seco (Lanzarote, Canary Islands) 2010

This one was truly interesting. The texture of the wine was creamy and acidic- the texture reminded me of Meursault (but not the flavors). 

That there on the top is the label (pretty minimalistic!). This one has an esoteric bottle design to boot. You can sort of see it on the left-- the lip has a slight pour spout built right in! 

Picture
Ricci "Terre del Timorasso" (Piemonte, Italy) 2009

This is a pretty interesting grape native to this region-- small production, only about 50 hectares planted. Smells like fresh bread & ripe pears. Tart acidity, creamy texture, starfruit flavor, and a sizzly minerality that lingers a bit. 

Picture
Banyan gewurztraminer (Monterey County, CA) 2011


This pretty inexpensive bottle (about $10ish) turned out to be quite pretty and was a favorite of the group. Persimmon, quince, some lychee, and a great florality; really open fruit with a zingy tartness to it. Really nice. 

And whodathunk? Pretty gewurtz from Central Cali... 

Picture



Chateau d'Auvernier chasselas (Neuchatel, Switzerland) 2009


This one was so rich and thick, but still had great acidity. We imagined how perfect it would be with a creamy cheese or a pate. A food wine for sure. 

Picture
Paolo Bea "Chiara" grechetto,malvasia,garganega+  (Umbria, Italy) 2009 

If this isn't an orange wine I don't know what is! We ended with this intriguing gem.
Nectar, apricots, beeswax, oregano; soft skin tannins from the longer maceration and an acidity that is almost crunchy-- like a watermelon rind. 

Picture
We sat in front of this rustic cellar wall during the tasting. It was a perfect environment for wine drinking. 

As we drank Bea's Chiara, we happened to look up and saw.......

Picture
his Sagrantino smiling down on us! 


0 Comments
    Picture
    _

    Follow @ErinBScala
    Instagram

    Erin

    I’m Erin, and this is my wine blog. Here, you'll find information about wines from around the world, and Virginia.  


    Top Posts

    Elizabeth Bird
    Sommelier History
    Stars & Terroir
    Dry German Wine
    1962 NYC Wine List

      Want to subscribe?

    Submit

    Archives

    December 2021
    May 2021
    June 2018
    October 2017
    September 2017
    August 2017
    July 2017
    June 2017
    April 2017
    March 2017
    February 2017
    November 2016
    October 2016
    August 2016
    July 2016
    June 2016
    January 2016
    February 2015
    January 2015
    December 2014
    November 2014
    October 2014
    September 2014
    August 2014
    July 2014
    June 2014
    May 2014
    April 2014
    March 2014
    February 2014
    January 2014
    December 2013
    November 2013
    October 2013
    September 2013
    August 2013
    July 2013
    June 2013
    May 2013
    April 2013
    March 2013
    February 2013
    January 2013
    December 2012
    November 2012
    October 2012
    September 2012
    August 2012
    July 2012
    June 2012
    May 2012
    April 2012
    March 2012
    February 2012
    January 2012
    December 2011

    RSS Feed

    Picture